What's in the water after flooding?

Environmental activists say they have proof of a coal ash leak into the Neuse River during the flooding after Hurricane Matthew. Duke Energy says the substance visible on the water is not coal ash and is not toxic.
Posted 10/20/2016, 1:14:17 AM Updated 9/23/2025, 7:51:32 PM

SOUTH ENVIRONMENTAL ACTIVISTS

SAY THEY HAVE PROOF OF A COAL

ASH LEAK INTO THE NEUSE RIVER

IN THE FLOODING AFTER MURTHA.

DUKE NEWSCHANNEL SAYS NOT ONLY

IS IT NOT COAL ASH BUT IT IS

NOT TOXIC.

>> KATHRYN BROWN IS LIVE

DOWNTOWN AT DUKE HEADQUARTER

WITH A CLOSER LOOK AT WHAT IS

IN THE WATER.

IS IT OR ISN'T IT, KATHRYN?

>> Reporter: WELL, DAVID, THAT

IS THE BIG QUESTION.

IT IS SOMEWHAT ALARMING TO SEE

THAT WHITE SUBSTANCE FLOATING

IN THE WATER.

BOTH SIDES AGREE ON THAT.

AND WE SAW IT FOR OURSELVES

TODAY DURING A BOAT RIDE.

WHILE DUKE ENERGY SAYS IT IS

NOT COAL ASH, THEY EMPHATICALLY

SAY THAT, ENVIRONMENTAL GROUPS

SAY IT IS.

ON THE BANKS OF THE SWOLLEN

NEUSE RIVER, ENVIRONMENTAL

ACTIVISTS SKIM FOR WHAT THEY

SAY IS TOXIC EVIDENCE OF A COAL

ASH SPILL.

THIS PART OF THE RIVER IS

ADJACENT TO THREE ENACTIVE COAL

ASH PITS AT THE H. F. LEE STEAM

PLANT IN GOLDSBORO.

THEY ARE FLOODED AFTER

HURRICANE MATTHEW.

STEVE HARRISON WITH WATER KEEP

ANTERIOR LINES BELIEVES THE

PITS WERE COMPROMISED AND THIS

WHITE STUB ASSISTANCE IN THE

TREES AND FLOATING ON THE WATER

A TYPE OF COAL ASH CALLED FLY

ASH.

>> YOU SEE RIGHT HERE ALONG THE

WATER'S END WHERE THE TREE IS,

AND YOU SEE THAT GRAY-WHITE

LINE, THAT IS MORE COAL ASH.

>> WE ARE JUST BAY MILE AND A

HALF UPSTREAM OF WHERE THE

SPILL SITE IS.

YOU CAN SEE THE TREES HERE THAT

WERE COVERED UNDER WATER JUST

THE SAME AS THE ONES DOWN

THERE.

BUT THEY ONLY HAVE A SMALL A

REAL FINE SEDIMENT.

>> I THINK AWHAT THIS SHOWS US

IS IT IS INHERENTLY DANGEROUS

TO STORE COAL ASH IN UNLINED

PITS IN THE FLOOD ZONES OF

MAJOR RIVERS.

>> Reporter: DUKE SPOKESMAN

JEFF BROOKS SAYS THE WHITE

SUBSTANCE ISN'T FLY ASH BUT WAS

CALL CENOSPHERES.

>> THEY FREELY EXIST ON TOP OF

OUR ASH BUSINESS INMENT THEY

ARE HARVESTED ON A REGULAR

BASIS AND SO THEY ARE NOT

INHERENTLY TOXIN BY NATURE.

EVEN IF IT WERE FLY ASH, IT IS

NOT INHERENTLY HAZARDOUS BY

ITSELF.

BUT THIS IS NOT FLY ASH THAT

WE'RE SEEING.

.

>> Reporter: DUKE ENERGY

ACKNOWLEDGED THAT SOME COAL ASH

WAS DISPLACED DURING THE

FLOODS.

THE STATE DEPARTMENT OF

ENVIRONMENTAL QUALITY SAID THAT

WAS ABOUT THE AMOUNT THAT COULD

FIT INTO A PICKUP TRUCK.

THEY SAID IT WAS NOT TOXIC.

ENVIRONMENTAL GROUPS, NO

SURPRISE, DISAGREE WITH THIS

STRONGLY.

BOTH SIDE DOING THEIR OWN